patternMinor
We can control tcp/udp traffic using router. Then why is it in Network layer and not transport layer?
Viewed 0 times
canwhylayercontroltrafficudptcproutertransportusing
Problem
Routers make use of the IP address, etc to shape the traffic. So obviously they must reside in at least the Network layer.
However we can also shape the traffic using tcp/udp. Routers usually have the port forwarding feature which allows them to shape the tcp/udp traffic.
The IP header has a field for protocol. However that doesn't show whether the traffic is udp/tcp. This information must be present inside the payload part of the IP packet. Then why is the router able to see that information despite being in the Network Layer?
However we can also shape the traffic using tcp/udp. Routers usually have the port forwarding feature which allows them to shape the tcp/udp traffic.
The IP header has a field for protocol. However that doesn't show whether the traffic is udp/tcp. This information must be present inside the payload part of the IP packet. Then why is the router able to see that information despite being in the Network Layer?
Solution
Because routers are real concrete devices, not theoretical constructs. They aren't limited by layering diagrams. Layering is a form of abstraction, which is a convention; there's nothing that prevents a device from inspecting and acting on the rest of the packet.
Separately: layering diagrams are a model, but not a perfect one. Real devices violate layering from time to time. The OSI 7-layer model is especially approximate -- don't take it too seriously. See, e.g., Till which layer does the loopback packet goes? and can network layers communicate between each other?.
Separately: layering diagrams are a model, but not a perfect one. Real devices violate layering from time to time. The OSI 7-layer model is especially approximate -- don't take it too seriously. See, e.g., Till which layer does the loopback packet goes? and can network layers communicate between each other?.
Context
StackExchange Computer Science Q#69058, answer score: 2
Revisions (0)
No revisions yet.