patternsqlMajor
MySQL: Which join is better between left outer join and inner join
Viewed 0 times
leftandbetterjoinmysqlbetweenwhichinnerouter
Problem
Which join is better peforming if all of them provides the same result?
For example, I have a two tables
For example, I have a two tables
employees(emp_id,name, address, designation, age, sex) and work_log(emp_id,date,hours_wored). To get some specific results both inner join and left join gives the same result. But, I have still some doubts which is not limited to this question only.- which join is more efficient which should prefer in case of same result values ?
- What are other factors which must be considered at the time of applying join?
- Is there any relationship between inner join and cross join?
Solution
There is not a "better" or a "worse" join type. They have different meaning and they must be used depending on it.
In your case, you probably do not have employees with no
Image by C.L. Moffatt on Code Project
Again, performance is a secondary thing to query correctness. Some people say that you shouldn't use
In summary, do not use
In MySQL
You have examples of all semantic types of join on Wikipedia. In practice, in MySQL, we tend to only write
In your case, you probably do not have employees with no
work_log (no rows in that table), so LEFT JOIN and JOIN will be equivalent in results. However, if you had such a thing (a new employee with no registered work_log), a JOIN wold omit that employee, while a left join (whose first table is employees) would show all of them, and nulls on the fields from work_log if there are not matches.Image by C.L. Moffatt on Code Project
Again, performance is a secondary thing to query correctness. Some people say that you shouldn't use
LEFT JOINs. It is true that a LEFT JOIN forces the optimizer to execute the query in one particular order, preventing some optimizations (table reordering) in some cases. Here is one example. But you should not choose one over the other if correctness/meaning is sacrificed, as an INNER JOIN is not inherently worse. The rest of the usual optimizations apply as usual.In summary, do not use
LEFT JOIN if you really mean INNER JOIN.In MySQL
CROSS JOIN, INNER JOIN and JOIN are the same. In the standard, and semantically, a CROSS JOIN is an INNER JOIN without an ON clause, so you get every combination of rows between tables.You have examples of all semantic types of join on Wikipedia. In practice, in MySQL, we tend to only write
JOIN and LEFT JOIN.Context
StackExchange Database Administrators Q#73087, answer score: 29
Revisions (0)
No revisions yet.