principlesqlMinor
Execution plan caching of ITVF called with inline vs dynamic SQL
Viewed 0 times
calledwithsqlcachingitvfplandynamicinlineexecution
Problem
I would like someone to explain to me how each of the two queries below would generate their execution plan in SQL Server where my function
Dynamic SQL
Inline SQL
Background
The Dynamic SQL is what's generated from a C# application that I'm working on and while it performs just as well as the Inline SQL most of the time it performs poorly for certain values of
I've read up on how this is caused by Parameter Sniffing and I've tried using
I feel like I need to find a way to force C# to create the Inline SQL so that it will use the exact execution plan for the given parameters instead of creating one on the fly with
[dbo].[GetAdditionalProjectDatesForCalendar] is an ITVF (inline table-valued function):Dynamic SQL
sp_executesql N'SELECT * FROM [dbo].[GetAdditionalProjectDatesForCalendar]
(@Parameter1,@Parameter2)', @Parameter1 = 'Value1', @Parameter2 = 'Value2'Inline SQL
SELECT * FROM [dbo].[GetAdditionalProjectDatesForCalendar]
('Value1','Value2')Background
The Dynamic SQL is what's generated from a C# application that I'm working on and while it performs just as well as the Inline SQL most of the time it performs poorly for certain values of
@Parameter1 and @Parameter2.I've read up on how this is caused by Parameter Sniffing and I've tried using
option(recompile) with the Dynamic SQL but that hasn't improved the performance entirely.I feel like I need to find a way to force C# to create the Inline SQL so that it will use the exact execution plan for the given parameters instead of creating one on the fly with
option(recompile). I also think I can do this by writing my dynamic sql without using parameterization but I know that would introduce a SQL Injection risk.Solution
The
Taking the AdventureWorks example from Itzik Ben-Gan's comment on the article referenced in the question:
The execution plan for:
...shows the specific parameter values being inlined (so the
If we add the recompile query hint, a plan is generated for the specific values with parameter embedding enabled (so no sort):
If we wrap the query in
Adding
sp_executesql plan with OPTION (RECOMPILE) should be fully optimized for the specific parameter values on each call, with parameter embedding also enabled.Taking the AdventureWorks example from Itzik Ben-Gan's comment on the article referenced in the question:
CREATE FUNCTION dbo.F
(
@NameLike nvarchar(50),
@Sort tinyint
) RETURNS TABLE
AS
RETURN
SELECT TOP (5)
ProductID,
Name
FROM Production.Product
WHERE
@NameLike IS NULL
OR Name LIKE @NameLike
ORDER BY
CASE WHEN @Sort = 1 THEN ProductID ELSE NULL END ASC,
CASE WHEN @Sort = 2 THEN ProductID ELSE NULL END DESC,
CASE WHEN @Sort = 3 THEN Name ELSE NULL END ASC,
CASE WHEN @Sort = 4 THEN Name ELSE NULL END DESC;The execution plan for:
SELECT *
FROM dbo.F(N'K%', 3);...shows the specific parameter values being inlined (so the
@NameLike IS NULL is optimized away, enabling a seek) but parameter embedding does not take place so there is a Top N Sort for the ORDER BY clause:If we add the recompile query hint, a plan is generated for the specific values with parameter embedding enabled (so no sort):
SELECT *
FROM dbo.F(N'K%', 3)
OPTION (RECOMPILE);If we wrap the query in
sp_executesql we get neither inlining nor embedding, since the values are explicitly parameterized:EXECUTE sys.sp_executesql
N'SELECT * FROM dbo.F(@NameLike, @Sort)',
N'@NameLike nvarchar(50), @Sort tinyint',
@NameLike = N'K%', @Sort = 3;Adding
OPTION (RECOMPILE) enables both optimizations again:EXECUTE sys.sp_executesql
N'SELECT * FROM dbo.F(@NameLike, @Sort) OPTION (RECOMPILE)',
N'@NameLike nvarchar(50), @Sort tinyint',
@NameLike = N'K%', @Sort = 3;Code Snippets
CREATE FUNCTION dbo.F
(
@NameLike nvarchar(50),
@Sort tinyint
) RETURNS TABLE
AS
RETURN
SELECT TOP (5)
ProductID,
Name
FROM Production.Product
WHERE
@NameLike IS NULL
OR Name LIKE @NameLike
ORDER BY
CASE WHEN @Sort = 1 THEN ProductID ELSE NULL END ASC,
CASE WHEN @Sort = 2 THEN ProductID ELSE NULL END DESC,
CASE WHEN @Sort = 3 THEN Name ELSE NULL END ASC,
CASE WHEN @Sort = 4 THEN Name ELSE NULL END DESC;SELECT *
FROM dbo.F(N'K%', 3);SELECT *
FROM dbo.F(N'K%', 3)
OPTION (RECOMPILE);EXECUTE sys.sp_executesql
N'SELECT * FROM dbo.F(@NameLike, @Sort)',
N'@NameLike nvarchar(50), @Sort tinyint',
@NameLike = N'K%', @Sort = 3;EXECUTE sys.sp_executesql
N'SELECT * FROM dbo.F(@NameLike, @Sort) OPTION (RECOMPILE)',
N'@NameLike nvarchar(50), @Sort tinyint',
@NameLike = N'K%', @Sort = 3;Context
StackExchange Database Administrators Q#154758, answer score: 3
Revisions (0)
No revisions yet.