How to use a conditional ORDER BY in MySQL?

I have the table courses where we have some fields and also the field course(string), favorited(bool), favoritedDate(dateTime), dateUpload.

The teacher uploads the course and this date is stored in the dateUpload field. If the teacher flag this course as favorite this information is a number 1 in the field favorited and the date it was flagged is stored in the field favoritedDate.

Now I need to retrieve all courses from a specific teacher and then order the list by date: If the course is flagged favorited=1 should ordered by favoritedDate,dateUpload desc, if favorited=0 should be ordered only by dateUpload desc.

This is what I have so far but it is not working:

SELECT * from courses where teacherId = 23 
ORDER BY 
  CASE favorited WHEN 1 THEN favoritedDate, dateUpload
    else dateUpload
  END
  DESC
;

Any idea how to solve this?

As Lennart explains, a CASE expression in MySQL can only produce a single value, not two or more. I think this would suite your problem:

ORDER BY
    CASE WHEN favorited = 1 THEN 0 ELSE 1 END,
    CASE WHEN favorited = 1 THEN favoritedDate END,
    dateUpload DESC ;

If the favoritedDate values are NULL when the item is not "favourited", then you really don't need the favorited column at all. The information is stored in favoritedDate: If it's null, it's not a favourite. If it's not null, it is. The ORDER BY in that case (not much simpler, due to MySQL sorting nulls before not null values):

ORDER BY
    (favoritedDate IS NULL),
    favoritedDate,
    dateUpload DESC ;

StackExchange Database Administrators Q#201719, answer score: 6