patternModerate
x64 Assembly - checking for largest prime factor
Viewed 0 times
x64checkinglargestassemblyforfactorprime
Problem
Using x64 assembly, I solved the Largest Prime Factor problem on Project Euler.
The problem is as follows:
The prime factors of 13195 are 5, 7, 13 and 29.
What is the largest prime factor of the number 600851475143 ?
The answer is 6857.
I think I have a top notch algorithm to do the job (speed wise), which doesn't actually check if a number is prime. The algorithm just reduces the number they gave you instead.
I am a beginner in assembly, and this is one of my first x64 assembly programs. Are there any standard conventions that I am not following, or general things that could have been done better? Any advice? Is there a simpler way to do wh
The problem is as follows:
The prime factors of 13195 are 5, 7, 13 and 29.
What is the largest prime factor of the number 600851475143 ?
The answer is 6857.
I think I have a top notch algorithm to do the job (speed wise), which doesn't actually check if a number is prime. The algorithm just reduces the number they gave you instead.
p3 proc
mov rbx, 600851475143 ; The original number
mov rcx, 1 ; The starting position of the counter
mov rdx, 0 ; Just to clear garbage data
mainloop:
mov rax, rbx ; rbx hold the number, and saves it, because the number in rax will change, and a backup needs to be stored
inc rcx ; Increment counter
noinc: ; This is where the loop starts at each iteration that the previous division operation had no remainder
mov rbx, rax ; At this instruction, we know that rax has been reduced, and save it into rbx
cmp rax, rcx ; These two lines check if the counter rcx reached its maximum value, and if so, the program quits and returns the result in rax
je done
mov rdx, 0 ; makes sure there is no junk data in rdx
div rcx ; Perform division to check for a remainder
cmp rdx, 0
jz noinc ; If there is no remainder: Reduce the value and dont increment next iteration
jnz mainloop ; If there is a remainder, jump back to the top of the loop, increment the value, and try the division again.
done: ; Exit
ret
p3 endpI am a beginner in assembly, and this is one of my first x64 assembly programs. Are there any standard conventions that I am not following, or general things that could have been done better? Any advice? Is there a simpler way to do wh
Solution
One optimisation that would make your code run up to twice as fast, is to use the observation that a prime factor of
Additionally, you know that once you have tested for divisibility by 2, then subsequent trial divisions can skip all even numbers. If you continue down this road, you'll eventually implement a prime sieve using all the same tricks.
One thing I would suggest is to use
It probably doesn't matter, but you could move the
n cannot be greater than n/2. So you can limit the number of times you iterate through your loop.Additionally, you know that once you have tested for divisibility by 2, then subsequent trial divisions can skip all even numbers. If you continue down this road, you'll eventually implement a prime sieve using all the same tricks.
One thing I would suggest is to use
jmp instead of jnz at the bottom of the loop. It might or might not make a performance difference, but you'll avoid the CPU (and your readers) from having to think about the condition.It probably doesn't matter, but you could move the
mov rdx, 0 up above the noinc label because whenever you jz noinc, you already know that rdx is zero. This sort of thing really needs to be clearly documented, of course.Context
StackExchange Code Review Q#55078, answer score: 12
Revisions (0)
No revisions yet.